Monarchy not feasible in Nepal

Refer to ‘Nepal can ill afford return of monarchy’; the recent pro-monarch demonstrations are a result of deep anger, dissatisfaction and resentment of the people against the main political parties who have been alternately sharing power for the last two decades. Monarchy was abolished in 2008 and a new Constitution was established in 2015, declaring the country a federal democratic republic. Systemic and political instability have led to mass migration of youth, poor industrialisation and slow economic growth. The revival of monarchy is not feasible because the country has evolved into a democracy. India must remain vigilant but indifferent to the political developments in Nepal as both nations share strong ties.

Harbinder S Dhillon, Una

Judicial overreach

Apropos of ‘Judiciary vs executive: 2 nations, 1 tense story’; Article 142 gives power to the Supreme Court to pass any order as necessary for rendering ‘complete’ justice. But it was envisioned as an ‘extraordinary’ remedy and not a measure to be taken by the court in any dispute between the Centre and states. Courts do strike down laws passed by legislatures as unconstitutional after a detailed hearing. But the apex court setting a timeline for the President, the head of State, to take a call on Bills appears to be a clear case of judicial overreach.

V Jayaraman, Chennai

Mutual respect necessary

Institutional friction carries significant consequences for democratic accountability and constitutional balance. When the executive sidesteps judicial orders or uses rhetoric to delegitimise courts, it strikes at the core of the checks-and-balances system. Conversely, when the judiciary begins to legislate rather than interpret, it risks weakening its own credibility and constitutional role. The metaphor ‘It’s a delicate dance. But it needs both partners’ aptly emphasises the need for mutual respect and harmony between these pillars of democracy. Robust civic education must also be disseminated so that an informed citizenry can act as a vigilante.

Ashok Singh Guleria, Hamirpur

Rebuild trust in Marathi manoos

Refer to ‘Thackeray thaw’; Maharashtra stands at a political crossroads today. The idea of regional identity, once fiercely championed by the Shiv Sena, has been diluted in recent years amidst factional splits, ideological shifts and the growing dominance of national parties. While leadership tussles and family dynamics often grab headlines, the larger issue remains unaddressed — who will articulate a vision that truly speaks for the Marathi manoos and addresses the unique socio-economic challenges of the state? The erosion of local political capital has given way to a national narrative that often sidelines regional priorities. The upcoming BMC elections are more than a battle for municipal control —they will be a referendum on the future of regional parties in the state.

Sanjay Chopra, Mohali

Kidney transplant now easier

Refer to ‘Kidney swap policy’; this step may prove to be a game-changer for the patients awaiting transplants. It should have been done much earlier, keeping in mind the huge number of patients who require transplants. Kidney rackets have been unearthed many times. The process of swap transplant approvals must be made transparent, foolproof and speedy. This will help reduce the number of kidney patients, alleviate their pain of regular dialysis and improve the rest of their lives. A campaign for voluntary organ donation, as was done earlier to raise awareness about blood donation, may prove helpful.

Wg Cdr JS Minhas (Retd), Mohali

Lifesaving policy reform

Apropos of ‘Kidney swap policy’; a centralised mechanism can revolutionise access by enabling nationwide matches, especially for patients living in different states. The recent success of paired donations in Ahmedabad shows this model’s promise, provided approvals are swift and processes transparent. Redefining ‘near relative’ and ensuring strict oversight are vital to restore public trust. If properly executed, this reform can turn despair into hope for thousands awaiting a second chance at life.

Amarjeet Mann, Una

Letters to the Editor